Blog / Workers' Compensation

Statutory Presumptions needed to protect workers

Statutory Presumptions needed to protect workers

Workers’ compensation benefits provide injured workers and their families with critical support while they recover from a work-related injury.

However, the process of obtaining workers’ compensation benefits can sometimes be a challenge. Thankfully, several statutory presumptions can make this process easier for certain workers to collect the benefits they need.

What is a statutory presumption?

A legal presumption is an understanding or belief under the law that the court assumes to be true. In sets of facts or circumstances with room for debate, a presumption tips the scale for a judge, jury, or commissioner to assume that one side of the argument is correct on its face. For example, Maryland has a presumption statute that assumes certain diseases are linked to a firefighter’s work (Maryland Code, Labor & Employment §9-503). This means they can collect workers’ compensation for several types of diseases, including:

  • Heart disease
  • Hypertension
  • Lung disease
  • Various types of cancer

In general, the above conditions may be linked to genetics, nutrition, exercise, or personal health habits, which make it difficult to pinpoint the cause of the condition. However, in relation to firefighters, their work is unique with the constant exposure risk to carcinogens from a fire ground and the diesel firetrucks they operate. Additionally, in light of firefighters’ service to the community, lawmakers sought to lower the legal threshold to ensure coverage of such workers.

Therefore, the law presumes that these diseases are tied to the firefighter’s work, providing them with an easier path to recover workers’ compensation benefits.

Without a statutory presumption, it is often very difficult to prove that certain diseases are causally related to a work exposure. Injured workers covered by a statutory presumption have a lower burden of proof, and, in other words, a lower hurdle of proving their occupational disease arose out of and is related to their employment.

Will there be a presumption statute for COVID-19?

In Maryland there is no statutory presumption that a person who has been diagnosed with COVID-19 has received the illness from a workplace exposure, even if they are an essential employee that works within close proximity of other people. However, there has been consideration in other states to facilitate access to recover workers’ compensation benefits for such workers.

So far, states like Kentucky, Florida, Washington and Minnesota have passed presumption statutes related to COVID-19. These statutes presume that if a “frontline worker” gets the disease, they contracted it on the job. These workers include, but are not limited to:

  • Health care workers
  • Grocery store workers
  • Food manufacturers
  • Prison guards

Maryland has yet to pass such a presumption statute to protect these workers, but unions and other employee advocacy organizations have considered such an important presumption for the working people of Maryland. Presently, Maryland’s legislature is not in session to consider such a beneficial law.

However, if a worker has continued to serve the public during the pandemic and is diagnosed with COVID-19, it would still be beneficial to contact an attorney to discuss a potential Claim. Although there is no presumption presently in Maryland, the law still entitles workers to benefits who experience an occupational disease as a result of employment.

Posted in:

Related Posts

Drug use can complicate workers’ comp claims

Drug use can complicate workers’ comp claims

Drug use in the workplace can inspire serious consequences for both workers who are trying to avoid occupational harm and for some who have already suffered due to work-related circumstances. For example, in Maryland, workers who are injured on the job are generally entitled to benefits regardless of fault. However, if drug use played a role in causing their work-related harm, those benefits can be denied or significantly reduced. Proving—or disproving—that connection often becomes a central issue in workplace injury cases involving positive drug tests. Workers’ comp is a no-fault system… most of the time Under Maryland law, employers or their insurers can argue that intoxication or drug impairment was the primary cause of an accident. If successful, this defense can prevent an injured worker from receiving compensation for medical care, lost wages or disability. The key question is causation: Did the drug use directly contribute to the injury, or did the accident occur independently of any impairment? For example, a worker who tests positive for an illegal substance after being struck by falling equipment may still be eligible for benefits if their impairment had no role in the incident at issue. Recent research underscores how pervasive workplace drug use has become in recent years. For example, a recent survey published by the National Safety Council indicates that one-third of American workers have witnessed the use of cannabis by others during work hours. Additionally, “More than half of employers that eliminated THC testing reported an increase in incidents or workplace performance concerns.” This trend suggests that many workers use marijuana while on the clock, potentially due to stress, chronic pain or “simply” accessibility. Marijuana use can cause drowsiness, confusion, apathy and slowed reaction times—all of which heighten the risk of workplace accidents. Even so, a positive drug test does not automatically disqualify a worker from receiving benefits. The Maryland Workers’ Compensation Commission requires evidence that the intoxication directly caused the injury at issue in a workers’ claim. A skilled legal team can help affected workers – who are obviously not alone, given the widespread nature of drug use in the workplace – to make their case as successfully as possible. Employers and insurers often use drug test results to limit liability, but workers still have rights. Anyone facing a disputed claim due to alleged drug use is generally wise to seek immediate legal guidance accordingly.

Has your knee been injured in a work-related fall?

Has your knee been injured in a work-related fall?

Unpredictability is one of the most dangerous things about falls. They can happen to anyone at any time, including in the workplace. Many times, you may be able to simply dust yourself off after a fall and get on with your day. Sadly, however, this is often not the case. Falls can be hard on your knees, and the resulting injuries can be serious. Outlined below are some of the more severe knee injuries associated with work-related falls. Damaged ligaments Torn ligaments are among the more serious and painful knee injuries that can result from a fall. The knee is comprised of four ligaments: the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL), the posterior cruciate ligament (PCL), the medial collateral ligament (MCL) and the lateral collateral ligament (LCL). Ligaments help the knee move forward and backward, as well as to rotate from side to side. Because each of these ligaments has a distinct function, damage to any of them can be painful and limit your mobility. Surgery and an extended period of recovery are often the only way to get better after ligament damage to avoid chronic pain issues. Dislocations During a fall, your knee may be manipulated and twisted into positions it is not designed to be in. This can result in a dislocation, which is very painful and can be difficult to treat. As a general rule, the sooner you seek medical treatment after this type of injury the better. Depending on whether or not there is nerve damage, you may require multiple surgeries before you can get back on your feet. If your knee has been injured in a fall at work, then you may be entitled to compensation for your pain and suffering. This won’t undo the damage, but it will help you to stay on top of your finances while you recover and are unable to work. Seeking legal guidance will offer you the best possible chance at obtaining a just outcome in your case.

No broken bones? You may still qualify for workers’ compensation in Maryland

No broken bones? You may still qualify for workers’ compensation in Maryland

One of the biggest misconceptions I hear from injured workers is, “I didn’t break anything, so I probably don’t have a workers’ compensation case.” That simply is not true. In Maryland, many legitimate workers’ compensation claims involve injuries that never show up on an X-ray. Some of the most serious work injuries I see start as what a worker believes is “just a strain” or “just some soreness.” A warehouse employee lifts a heavy box and feels a pull in their back. A healthcare worker develops shoulder pain after repeatedly moving patients. A construction worker twists a knee stepping off equipment. None of these injuries involve broken bones, but all can affect a person’s ability to work and earn a living. Workers’ compensation covers more than broken bones Maryland workers’ compensation benefits are available for many job-related injuries, including those that develop gradually or involve soft tissue rather than fractures. Common workplace injuries that may qualify include: Back strains and sprains Neck injuries Shoulder injuries Knee and ankle injuries Repetitive stress injuries Soft-tissue injuries Aggravation of pre-existing conditions Injuries that require medical treatment, work restrictions or time off The question is not whether an injury appears dramatic. The question is whether the injury arose out of and in the course of employment and whether it affects your ability to perform your job. Why workers often hurt their own claims After more than 17 years representing injured workers, I've seen the same mistake over and over again. Someone gets hurt at work, but they decide to “tough it out.” They finish their shift. They wait a few days. Maybe they assume the pain will go away on its own. Then the pain gets worse. By the time they report the injury, the insurance company may start asking questions: Why wasn’t the injury reported immediately? Did something happen outside of work? Is this really a work-related injury? That does not mean the claim is lost, but it can make the process more difficult than it needs to be. If you are injured at work, report the injury promptly and seek appropriate medical treatment. Early documentation often becomes important evidence later. What if you already had a pre-existing condition? Another common misconception is that workers’ compensation only applies to perfectly healthy workers. That is not how Maryland workers’ compensation law works. Many workers have prior back problems, arthritis, old injuries, or degenerative conditions. If a workplace accident aggravates, accelerates, or worsens that condition, workers’ compensation benefits may still be available. Insurance companies frequently argue that pain is related to age, degeneration, or a prior injury rather than a workplace accident. That is why medical records, timely reporting, and a clear history of what occurred at work can be so important. Why moderate injury claims are often disputed Ironically, some moderate injuries face more scrutiny than obvious catastrophic injuries. A broken bone is easy to see on an X-ray. Soft-tissue injuries, strains, sprains, and pain-related conditions often require a closer review of medical records, treatment history, work restrictions, and physician opinions. Insurance companies may schedule independent medical examinations (IMEs) or dispute whether treatment is necessary. In some cases, disputes must be resolved before the Maryland Workers’ Compensation Commission. Just because an injury is not visible on an imaging study does not mean it is not real. When should you speak with a workers’ compensation attorney? If a work injury is causing pain, limiting your movement, forcing you to miss work, or affecting your ability to perform your job, it may be worth speaking with an attorney about your rights. Too many workers assume they do not have a case because they never went to the emergency room or because nothing was broken. That assumption can be costly. At Cohen, Snyder & Eisenberg, we regularly help Maryland workers navigate claims involving strains, sprains, repetitive stress injuries, and other injuries that may not appear serious at first but can have a significant impact on a person’s ability to work. If you were injured on the job, do not assume you are ineligible for benefits simply because there were no broken bones. What matters is how the injury occurred and how it affects your ability to earn a living.